Quick Check Pump Performance Using Motor Data and Field Measure Current

Display problem ? Click HERE

Recommended :
- Subscribe FREE - World Pumpv (USA & Europe only)
- Tips on Succession in FREE Subscription

There is a centrifugal pump working on the field and a flow meter is continuously measuring the flow rate delivered by the centrifugal pump. You noticed that flow meter indicating flow rate same as normal recorded flow rate, however, the downstream system indicating that there is reduction in flow. Flow meter Calibration is one of the normal way to confirm if the flow meter is working correctly. Prior to this, you may consider the following approach to quickly check if the pump delivering good flow and cross check with the flow meter.

This approach basically use the field tested pump curve as follow.

Field tested pump curve

Pump power consumed by pump shaft,

Es = (dH x Q x SG) / (3960 x Pump Eff. x Kv) [Eq. 1]

where,
Es = Pump shaft power (HP) consumed
dH = Pump head (ft)
SG = fluid specific gravity
Pump Eff. = Pump efficiency
Kv = Viscosity Correction Factor

Power deliver by a motor to pump shaft,

Em = (1.732 x V x I x Motor Eff. x P.F.) / (746) [Eq. 2]

where,
Em = Power deliver by motor to pump shaft
V = Voltage (v)
I = Current (amp)
Motor eff. = Motor efficiency
P.F. = Motor Power Factor

Recommended :
- Subscribe FREE - Power Engineering (USA, Canada & Mexico)
- Subcribe FREE - Power Engineering (International)

Case study
A centrifugal pump transferring water from tank to a drum. A pressure transmitter located on the pump discharge. This estimated pump head based on differential pressure is 2000 ft. Fluid SG is 0.9932. From field, Voltage and current for the centrifugal pump are 460 volts and 323.1 amp. The flow meter is indicating flow rate of 385 gpm. Check if the flow meter is correctly measuring the flow rate.

From motor catalog, you may obtain motor efficiency (motor Eff.) and power factor (P.F.). For example, a motor with Motor Eff = 95% and P.F.=90%. The motor efficiency and P.F. may varies a bit (2%-5%). But they can be assumed same.

Power consumed / delivered,
From [Eq. 2],
==> Em = (1.732 x V x I x Motor Eff. x P.F.) / (746)
==> Em = (1.732 x 460 x 323.1 x 0.95 x 0.9) / (746)
==> Em = 295 HP

From above pump curve,
With Em = 295 HP
==> Flow, Q = 400 gpm, Pump Eff. 68% and Pump Head = 2000 ft.

Q = 400 gpm > 385 gpm as measured by flow meter. This indicates that the flow meter may not perform correctly.

Cross check with [Eq. 1],
As fluid is water,
==> Kv = 1.

For other type of fluid, may check out the viscosity correction factor using curve (by HI) presented in "Quick Check if Pump Performance Curve (Water) is Good for High Viscosity Fluid".

From [Eq. 1],
==> Es = (dH x Q x SG) / (3960 x Pump Eff. x Kv)
==> Q= Es x (3960 x Pump Eff. x Kv) / (dH x SG)
==> Q= 295 x (3960 x 0.68 x 1) / (2000 x 0.9932)
==> Q = 400 gpm


It is useful to generate a Current versus Flow curve as follow :

Current versus Flow curve

With this curve, operator may use it quickly check against the flow meter.

Related Topic

• Is PumpSmart Right Solution for You ?
• Special Flowmeter & Piping Release...
• Vortex Breaker to Avoid Vapor Entrainment
• Estimate Minimum Submergence to Avoid Vapor Entrainment
• Estimate Pump Power Consumption without Vendor Information
• Trim Centrifugal Pump Impeller for Reduced Head
• Quick Check if Pump Performance Curve (Water) is Good for High Viscosity Fluid